Black History Frequently Asked Questions Helpful Links
The 104th Psalm by John Quincy Adams Abigail Adams' Letter Abraham Lincoln General Order Abraham Lincoln Portrait & Emancipation Proclamation Aitken Bible The American Bible Society American Bible Society Certificate Signed by John Jay Andrew Carnegie Letter Attempted Capture of John Hancock and Samuel Adams Battle of Trenton Benjamin Rush Letter to Elisha Boudinot Benjamin Rush Personal Bible Study Bible Society Reports Black Revolutionary War Soldiers Pay Charles Carroll Letter The Constitution of the United States of America D-Day Prayer Daniel Webster's Letter to the American Bible Society The Death of General Braddock The Declaration of Independence A Defence of the Use of the Bible in Schools Dwight D. Eisenhower's Inaugural Prayer Election Sermon First American Bible Society Bible The Four Chaplains Card Gen. Eisenhower's D-Day Message General Order Respecting the Observance of the Sabbath Harvard College Charter Jacob Broom Letter James Garfield Letter John Adams Letter to Benjamin Rush John Basilone Magazine Cover John Hancock - A Brief - 1788 John Hart Document John Quincy Adams Graduates from Harvard July 4th Prayer Lew Wallace Manumission - Christopher Johnson - 1782 Manumission - Dorcas - 1837 Manumission - Quaker - 1774 Noah Webster & The Bible Noah Webster Letters Noah Webster's Dictionary Noah Webster's "The Peculiar Doctrines of the Gospel Explained and Defended" Official White House Christmas Ornaments Paying Off the Barbary Pirates Philadelphia Bible Society Bible Philadelphia Bible Society Constitution Pony Express Bible Presidential Christmas Cards Proclamation - Lincoln Day - 1919, Massachusetts Richard Henry Lee Copy of John Adams Letter Robert Smalls Honored with Medal Samuel Chase Document Thomas Jefferson Document Truman Christmas Card 1950 War Bond Posters Washington Reading Prayers in His Camp Webster Regiment Wentworth Cheswell Documents Will of Richard Stockton Woodrow Wilson on the Christian Men's Association WWII Japanese Leaflets WWII Special Orders for German-American Relations
Oration - Pilgrims - 1853 Massachusetts Sermon - American Institutions & the Bible - 1876 Sermon - Artillery - 1847 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1792 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1798 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1803 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1808 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1809 Sermon - Artillery Election - 1853 Sermon - Atlantic Telegraph - 1858 Sermon - Battle of Lexington - 1776 Sermon - Battle of Lexington - 1778 Sermon - Before the Governor and Legislature - 1785 Connecticut Sermon - Before Judges - 1681 Sermon - Bridge Opening - 1805 Sermon - Bridge Opening - 1808 Sermon - Century - 1801 Sermon - Century - 1801 Sermon - Century - 1801 Sermon - Century Church Anniversary - 1814 Sermon - Christianity & Infidelity - 1880 Sermon - Christian Love - 1773 Sermon - Christian Patriot - Boston, 1840 Sermon - Christmas - 1788 Sermon - Christmas - 1818 Sermon - Christmas - 1838 Sermon - Christmas - 1841 Sermon - Christmas - 1843 Sermon - Christmas - 1844 Sermon - Church and Country - 1891 Sermon - Civil War - 1861 Sermon - Commercial Distress - 1837 Sermon - Communism in Churches - c. 1960 Sermon - Death of George Washington - 1800 Sermon - Dueling - 1805 Sermon - Dueling - Albany, 1838 Sermon - Earthquakes - 1755 Sermon - Easter - 1910 Sermon - Election - 1769, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1771, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1775, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1776, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1778, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1780, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1781, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1783, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1784, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1784, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1785, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1785, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1786, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1786, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1787, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1788, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1788, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1789, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1789, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1790, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1790, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1790, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1791, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1791, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1791, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1792, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1792, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1792, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1793, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1793, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1794, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1794, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1796, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1796, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1796, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1797, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1797, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1798, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1798, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1799, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1800, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1800, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1801, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1801, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1802, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1802, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1803, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1803, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1804, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1804, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1805, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1805, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1806, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1806, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1807, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1807, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1808, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1808, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1808, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1809, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1809, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1809, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1810, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1810, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1811, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1811, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1812, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1812, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1812, Vermont Sermon - Election - 1813, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1814, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1814, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1815, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1815, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1815, Vermont Sermon - Election - 1816, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1816, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1816, Vermont Sermon - Election - 1817, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1817, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1818, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1818, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1819, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1820, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1820, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1821, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1822, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1822, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1823, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1823, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1824, Massachusetts Sermon - Election - 1826, New Hampshire Sermon - Election - 1829, Vermont Sermon - Election - 1830, Connecticut Sermon - Election - 1856, Vermont Sermon - Election - 1861, New Hampshire Sermon - Establishing Public Happiness - 1795 Sermon - Eulogy - 1776 Sermon - Eulogy - 1784 Sermon - Eulogy - 1790 Sermon - Eulogy - 1793 Sermon - Eulogy - 1796 Sermon - Eulogy - 1799 Sermon - Eulogy - 1807 Sermon - Eulogy - 1834 Sermon - Eulogy - 1854 Sermon - Execution - 1770 Sermon - Execution - 1796 Sermon - Execution - 1797 Sermon - Execution - 1848 Sermon - Fasting - 1783, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1798 Sermon - Fasting - 1798 Sermon - Fasting - 1798 Sermon - Fasting - 1798 Sermon - Fasting - 1798 Sermon - Fasting - 1798, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1799 Sermon - Fasting - 1799 Sermon - Fasting - 1799, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1801, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1805, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1805, New Hampshire Sermon - Fasting - 1808, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1808, New York Sermon - Fasting - 1809, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1810, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1810, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1810, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1811, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1812 Sermon - Fasting - 1812 Sermon - Fasting - 1812 Sermon - Fasting - 1812 Sermon - Fasting - 1812 Sermon - Fasting - 1812, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1814, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1815 Sermon - Fasting - 1818, Massachusetts Sermon - Fasting - 1832, MA Sermon - Fire - 1840 Sermon - Fire - 1840 Sermon - Fugitive Slave Bill - 1850 Sermon - Fugitive Slave Bill - 1851 Sermon - George Washington's Birthday - 1863 Sermon - Giving - 1877 Sermon - Great Fire in Boston - 1760 Sermon - Hampshire Missionary Society - 1802 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1822 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1822 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1854 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1858 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1860 Sermon - House of Representatives - 1864 Sermon - In Boston - 1814 Sermon - The Infirmities and Comforts of Old Age - 1805 Sermon - Influence of the Gospel upon Intellectual Powers - 1835 Sermon - July 4th - 1794 Sermon - July 4th - 1825, Pennsylvania Sermon - Liberty - 1775 Sermon - Life & Character of Joseph Smith - 1877 Sermon - Living Faith - 1801 Sermon - Loss of Children - 1832 Sermon - Marriage - 1837 Sermon - Memorial Day Sermon - Memorial Day Sermon - Memorial Day - 1875 Sermon - Mexican War - 1848 Sermon - Military - 1755 Sermon - Modern Emigrant - 1832 Sermon - Moral Uses of the Sea - 1845 Sermon - Moral View of Rail Roads - 1851 Sermon - New Planet - 1847 Sermon - New Year - 1799 Sermon - New Year - 1861/ 1862 Sermon - Old Age Improved - 1811 Sermon - Ordination - 1773 Sermon - Ordination - 1779 Sermon - Ordination - 1789 Sermon - Ordination - 1790 Sermon - Ordination - 1793 Sermon - Ordination - 1817 Sermon - Overcoming Evil With Good - 1801 Sermon - People Responsible for Character of Rulers - 1895 Sermon - Perjury - 1813 Sermon - Pilgrims - 1793 Sermon - Pilgrims - 1820 Sermon - Pilgrims - 1827 Sermon - Pilgrims - 1846 Sermon - Prayer - 1799 Sermon - Property Tax - 1816 Sermon - Protestant Episcopal Church Convention - 1792 Sermon - Protestant Episcopal Church Convention - 1799 Sermon - Sabbath Day - 1803 Sermon - Saul Consulting Witch of Endor - 1806 Sermon - Slavery - 1791 Sermon - Snow and Vapor - 1856 Sermon - Society in Cambridge - 1802 Sermon - Society in Saybrook - 1803 Sermon - Solar Eclipse - 1806 Sermon - Stamp Act Repeal - 1766 Sermon - State Prison - 1812 Sermon - Succes Failure in Life - 1833 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1774 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1783 Massachusetts Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1785 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1794 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Massachusetts Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Pennsylvania Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1795 Philadelphia Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1798 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1798 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1798 Connecticut Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1803 Connecticut Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1804 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1804 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1808 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1814 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1815 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1825 Massachusetts Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1827 Yale Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1838 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1850 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1850 Connecticut Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1850 New York Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1852 Massachusetts Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1853 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1862 New York Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1863 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1864 Sermon - Thanksgiving - 1864 Connecticut Sermon - The Voice of Warning to Christians - 1800 Speech - House of Representatives - 1881
Abraham Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address Address - Historical - 1835 Address - July 4th - 1822, Connecticut Address - Why Are You A Christian - 1795 Benjamin Franklin's letter to Thomas Paine Discourse - The Birthday of George Washington - February, 1852 Discourse - July 4th - 1796, Massachusetts Discourse - July 4th - 1798, Connecticut Discourse - Settlement of Cape Cod - 1839 Dissertation - Right & Obligation of Civil Magistrate - 1804 Elias Boudinot's Age of Revelation The Founders As Christians The Founders on Gambling George Washington's Farewell Address "Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death" Importance of Morality and Religion in Government The Importance of Voting and Christian Involvement in the Political Arena John Jay on the Biblical View of War Letters Between the Danbury Baptists and Thomas Jefferson Oration - Anniversary of Continental Congress - 1874 Oration - Eulogy - 1832 Oration - July 4th - 1787, New York Oration - July 4th - 1796, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1801, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1804 Oration - July 4th - 1808 Oration - July 4th - 1810 Oration - July 4th - 1810, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1812, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1822 Oration - July 4th - 1825, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1826 Oration - July 4th - 1826, Cambridge Oration - July 4th - 1826, Massachusetts Oration - July 4th - 1827, Boston Oration - July 4th - 1831, Boston Oration - July 4th - 1831, Quincy Oration - July 4th- 1837 Oration - July 5th - 1824, Quincy Proclamation - Humiliation and Prayer - 1812 Qualifications for Public Office Report - Missionary Society - 1817 New York Should Christians - Or Ministers - Run For Office? Thomas Paine Criticizes the Current Public School Science Curriculum
The 2010 Election: The News Inside the News 4th of July Article Advancing the Sanctity of the Unborn Life in the Ft. Hood Massacre Affidavit in Support of the Ten Commandments African American History Resources The Aitken Bible and Congress America's Religious Heritage As Demonstrated in Presidential Inaugurations America: A Christian or a Secularist Nation? America’s Most Biblically-Hostile U. S. President The American Revolution: Was it an Act of Biblical Rebellion? American Voters and the Abortion Issue Analyzing Legislation An Article V Convention of the States Benjamin Rush Dream about John Adams and Thomas Jefferson The Bible and Taxes The Bible, Slavery, and America's Founders Biblical Christianity: The Origin of the Rights of Conscience A Black Patriot: Wentworth Cheswell Bob Barr Crosses the Line Calling Muslims to the Capitol? Celebrating Thanksgiving In America A Christian Voter Intimidation Letter from Americans United for Separation of Church and State Christmas With the Presidents Christmas-As Celebrated by the Presidents Church in the U.S. Capitol Churches And Elections - What Is The Law? Civic Ignorance on Display Confronting Civil War Revisionism: Why The South Went To War Congress, the Culture, and Christian Voting A Constitutional Amendment Restoring Religious Freedom David Barton & the ADL David Barton on President's Day Deconstructionism and the Left Defending The Jefferson Lies: David Barton Responds to his Conservative Critics Did George Washington Actually Say "So Help Me God" During His Inauguration? Echoes of 1860: Is "Life" a Question of State's Rights? Election 2004: A Moral Mandate? Election Resources and Information Electoral College: Preserve or Abolish? Ensuring Judicial Accountability For State Judges Evolution and the Law: “A Death Struggle Between Two Civilizations” Expatriation, Conscience, and a Worthless Oath of Office Federal Judges: Demigods? Five Judicial Myths The Founders And Public Religious Expressions The Founding Fathers on Creation and Evolution The Founding Fathers on Jesus, Christianity and the Bible The Founding Fathers and Slavery Franklin’s Appeal for Prayer at the Constitutional Convention Frequently Asked Questions Futile Intimidation Attempts George Washington, Thomas Jefferson & Slavery in Virginia God: Missing in Action from American History A Godless Constitution?: A Response to Kramnick and Moore Guns, Kids and Critics H.RES. 888 Health Care and the Constitution Hiroshima, Obama, and American Morals Historical Accounts of Thanksgiving Hobby Lobby - They Got It Right Homosexuals in the Military Houses of Worship Free Speech Restoration Act How Does Jeremiah 17:9 Relate to the Constitutional Separation of Powers? How to Respond to “Separation of Church and State” How You Can Be Involved Impeachment of Federal Judges In Hoc Anno Domini Is America a Christian Nation? James Madison and Religion in Public The Jefferson Lies: Taking on the Critics John Adams: Was He Really an Enemy of Christians? Addressing Modern Academic Shallownes John Locke – A Philosophical Founder of America John Locke: Deist or Theologian? Judges: Should they be Elected or Appointed? Letter to Pastors about Welfare Comment on Beck Radio Show Limiting an Overreaching Federal Government: Is State Nullification the Solution? The Meaning of Thanksgiving Meet The ACLU MexicoPolicyLetter No Professor Fea, The Founders Did Not Want Ministers to Stay out of Politics "One Nation Under God" Political Parties and Morality Political Parties and Racial Equality Potential Constitutional Problems With H.R. 3590 President Obama’s Misguided Sense of Moral Equivalency Presidential Protestors Don’t Understand America Private Property Rights Resolution Recommended Reading List Religious Acknowledgments in the Capitol Visitor Center Religious Activities at Presidential Inaugurations Republic v. Democracy A Review of A&E’s "The Crossing" Revisionism: How to Identify It In Your Children's Textbooks Sample Letters to the Editor The Separation of Church and State Solving the Pledge of Allegiance Controversy Stansbury's Elementary Catechism on the Constitution (1828) Statement: David Barton on The Jefferson Lies Steps for Viewing Candidates Scorecards The Story of the Star Spangled Banner Taking On The Critics A Tale of Two Constitutions Ten Commandments Displays Ten Steps To Change America Tea Parties- Same Song, Second Verse Testimony of David Barton on Global Warming Testimony on Global Warming Thomas Jefferson and Religion at the University of Virginia Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: The Search for Truth Treaty of Tripoli Unconfirmed Quotation: Franklin Principles of Primitive Christianity Unconfirmed Quotations War on God in America Was George Washington a Christian? The White House Attack on Religion Continues: Repealing Conscience Protection Who are the Racists and when did they Switch Political Parties? Why Christians Must Vote in This Election Your Vote Counts Video
A Soldier and a President 2011 Election Information 2011 ProFamily Legislators Conference Abraham Lincoln Addressing Mass Murder and Violent Crime America's Founders at College The American Bible Society American History: Bachmann v. Stephanopoulos Are You Smarter Than a Fourth Grader? The Barbary Powers Wars The Battle of Baltimore Bibles and the Founding Fathers Black Soldiers in the Revolution Brave Soldiers of the Cross A Call to Action Celebrate Columbus Day! Celebrate Constitution Day! Celebrate with Prayer! Celebrating Abigail Adams Celebrating Black History Month: The Rev. Francis J. Grimke Celebrating the Constitution Celebrating First Amendment Rights Christmas Message from Wartime Christmas Resolutions (2007) Christmas with the Presidents Congressional Prayer Caucus Conscience Protection Amendment - Call Your Senator Today! Conscience Protection Amendment Update The Constitution and a Duel - What do they have in Common? The Constitution and the Minority - What Does it All Mean? The Cost of Signing the Declaration of Independence The Courts and Religion: Are they Inimical? Daniel Webster: The Defender of the U.S. Constitution The Declaration Racist? Ha! Deconstructionism Dr. Benjamin Rush Draftsman of the Declaration A Family's Enduring Political Legacy The Finger of God on the Constitutional Convention Flying High The Founders on the Second Amendment Founding Fathers on Prayer The Four Chaplains Free to Speak George Washington First Becomes a National Leader George Washington's Birthday Getting Out the Vote A God-Given Inalienable Right A God-Given Inalienable Right Under Direct Attack A Great Price Paid Happy Easter! Happy Fourth of July! Happy Fourth of July! Happy Thanksgiving! Happy Thanksgiving! Happy Thanksgiving! The Heart Shield Bibles of World War II Hiroshima, Obama, and American Morals An Historic Look at Easter Historical Account of Thanksgiving Honor America's Veterans Honor a Veteran! How much do you know about the Constitution? In God We Trust Inspiring America: Nathan Hale Islamic Terrorism: Two Hundred Years Old? It Happened in March The Jefferson Lies John Dickinson John Quincy Adams - Abolitionist, President, & Father Join the Black Robe Regiment today! The Lesser Known Boudinot Martin Luther King, Jr. The Mayflower and Presidents - What do they have in common? Memorial Day National Bible Week 2007 NBC's "George Washington" and Spielberg's "Lincoln" Noah Webster On This Day In History: July 29, 1775 On This Day in History: June 28, 1787 The Pony Express The Power of the Pulpit President Eisenhower's One Nation Under God Presidents Day The Pulpit Initiative Read the Bible! The Real Story Behind Old Glory Register Congregations to Vote! Religious Freedom Day Religious Freedom Sunday Remember the "date which will live in infamy" this Christmas Season Remembering Pearl Harbor Remembering Pearl Harbor Remembering the Reason for Christmas The Response: A Call to Prayer For a Nation in Crisis The Response: An Historic Event Restoring Courage: Standing in Solidarity With Israel Ringing of the Liberty Bell Sam Houston Sanctity of Human Life Day Science and the Glory of God Secretary of the Continental Congress Charles Thomson A Secular Oath? A Southern View of Black History? The State of the Union Statement on the Supreme Court Decision Test Your Knowledge: John Quincy Adams Thanksgiving 2007 Their Lives, Fortunes and Sacred Honor: Richard Stockton This Day in History: D-Day This Day in History: Star Spangled Banner This Week in History: 1775 The Tomb of the Unknown Soldier - A Forgotten History? The Truth about Columbus United States Navy Vindicating American Exceptionalism The Webster Regiment What do you know about Naphtali Daggett? Which President earned the nickname "Old Man Eloquent"? Who Led the Plymouth Pilgrims? Who Was Charles Carroll? Who was the "Father of the Revolution"? Who was known as “First in war, First in peace, First in the hearts of his countrymen”? Women Heroes Women Who Shaped History World Trade Center Cross
Voter Resources

contribute




Sign up for our Mailing List!
Back to Issues and Articles



No Professor Fea, The Founders Did Not Want Ministers to Stay out of Politics
David Barton - 08/31/2016

No Professor Fea, The Founders Did Not Want Ministers to Stay out of Politics.

by Dr. David Barton

Dr. John Fea is a professor of history at Messiah College in Pennsylvania. He has been an outspoken critic of those who believe that America had a Christian founding or think ministers should be active in politics. 1 In addition to being an historian, he writes political columns praising those on the political left. For example, he called President Barack Obama “the most explicitly Christian president in American history,” and asserted that his “piety, use of the Bible, and references to Christian faith and theology put most other American presidents to shame.” 2 Given Professor Fea’s political disposition, it is perhaps not surprising that his blog posts and opinion pieces on political issues are regularly critical of religious conservatives.

For instance, Dr. Fea strongly objected when 700 pastors gathered to hear from Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump. The candidate addressed issues of immediate concern to some pastors, notably the Johnson Amendment – a 1954 law that many believe unconstitutionally prohibits churches from addressing or speaking about political issues or candidates. (In my view, whether or not churches should address issues of public policy or endorse candidates is a question that should be decided solely by individual churches, not the federal government.)

Fea seems particularly upset by the idea that these 700 ministers might exercise their rights as American citizens to be involved in politics. Misusing historical arguments to bolster his own personal views, he writes:

The founders who crafted the original state governments – those governments celebrated by today’s conservative politicians as the most important source of democratic life – thought it was a good idea for ministers to stay out of politics [emphasis added]. The state constitutions of North Carolina (1776), New York (1777), Georgia (1777), South Carolina (1778), Delaware (1792), Tennessee (1796), Maryland (1799), and Kentucky (1799) all banned clergymen from running for office. The 1776 North Carolina Constitution states “that no clergyman, or preacher of the gospel of any denomination, shall be capable of being a member of either the Senate, House of Commons, or Council of State, while he continues in the exercise of the pastoral function.” The 1777 New York Constitution uses similar language: “And whereas the ministers of the gospels are, by their profession, dedicated to the service of God and the care of souls, and ought not to be diverted from the great duties of their function; therefore, no minister of the gospel, or priest of any denomination whatsoever, shall, at any time hereafter, under any pretense of description whatever, be eligible to, or capable of holding, any civil or military office or place within this State.” 3

It is true that some state constitutions prohibited clergy from holding office. It is important to note that one reason they did so was because their framers had such a high view of the ministry that they did not want clergy to be distracted by “worldly” concerns. Yet only a small minority of states 4 ever attempted to exclude ministers from public office, and most states that did eventually decided these restrictions were inappropriate and voluntarily removed them. In 1978, the United States Supreme Court declared the few remaining disqualifications to be unconstitutional. 5

But it is not just states that changed their minds. Consider the views of Thomas Jefferson, often presented as one of the least religious of the Founding Fathers. The 1776 Virginia constitution contained a clergy-exclusion clause 6 that Jefferson originally supported, explaining:

The clergy are excluded because if admitted into the legislature at all, the probability is that they would form its majority, for they are dispersed through every county in the state; they have influence with the people and great opportunities of persuading them to elect them into the legislature. This body, though shattered, is still formidable, still forms a corps, and is still actuated by the esprit de corps. The nature of that spirit has been severely felt by mankind, and has filled the history of ten or twelve centuries with too many atrocities not to merit a proscription from meddling with government. 7

This was the early constitution of a state that, like many of the other states that excluded clergy from holding public office, had formally established the Church of England (that is, Anglicanism) as the colony’s official religion. Under these establishments the free exercise of religion was severely restricted for Quakers, Presbyterians, Methodists, Baptists, and other non-Anglicans, who were sometimes beaten, imprisoned, or fined by civic authorities joined to the state-established church. 8 Moreover, clergy from these established churches were far more likely to be Loyalists (that is supportive of Great Britain and opposed to American independence) than clergy from other denominations. Clergy-exclusion clauses generally were not enacted in states with a history of republican or patriotic ministers, such as Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.

Jefferson, being from Anglican Virginia, feared that the religious persecution that had occurred earlier in his state might return in the newly independent Virginia. He wanted that possibility precluded and thus supported the constitutional provision. He may have also been concerned about the loyalty of these Anglican clergy. But later, when the power of the state-established church in Virginia had been fully broken and a proven record of all Christian denominations being treated equally under the law had been thoroughly demonstrated, Jefferson no longer supported that clause, explaining in 1800 to the Rev. Jeremiah Moore:

I observe . . . an abridgment of the right of being elected, which after 17 years more of experience and reflection, I do not approve: it is the incapacitation of a clergyman from being elected. . . . Even in 1783, we doubted the stability of our recent measures for reducing them [the clergy] to the footing of other useful callings [but i]t now appears that our means were effectual. The clergy here seem to have relinquished all pretension to privilege and to stand on a footing with lawyers, physicians &c. They ought therefore to possess the same rights. 9

Not only did Jefferson think clergy should be able to run for office, there are even times when he encouraged them to do so. For instance, when he learned that his friend the Rev. Charles Clay was a candidate for Congress, he wrote him a letter wherein he wished him “every prosperity in this and in all your other undertakings.” 10 And he personally recruited the Rev. William Woods, a local Baptist pastor, to run for a seat in the state legislature. 11

As in Virginia, Georgia’s first state constitution contained a clause declaring: “No clergyman of any denomination shall be allowed a seat in the legislature.” 12 When Presbyterian minister and signer of the Declaration John Witherspoon learned of this provision, he was livid. He had invested much of his adult life in securing not only civil but also religious liberties for every individual, including ministers, and he was not about to see a reduction of those liberties. He therefore sent off a fiery public letter, pointedly asking Georgia’s lawmakers:

Now suffer me to ask this question: Before any man among us was ordained a minister, was he not a citizen of the United States, and if being in Georgia, a citizen of the state of Georgia? Had he not then a right to be elected a member of the assembly, if qualified in point of property? How then has he lost, or why is he deprived of this right? Is it by offence or disqualification? Is it a sin against the public to become a minister? Does it merit that the person who is guilty of it should be immediately deprived of one of his most important rights as a citizen? Is not this inflicting a penalty, which always supposes an offence? Is a minister then disqualified for the office of a senator or representative? Does this calling and profession render him stupid or ignorant? 13

Witherspoon then raised additional questions Georgia legislators apparently had not considered when drafting this clause. For example, what is it that makes a man a minister? Does he have to be ordained by the Pope? Or is it because his denomination or even local church considers him a minister? Or what if he simply declares himself a minister, with no confirmation by anyone else? Furthermore, how long is a person a minister? If he is retired, is he still disqualified from running? And what if he is bi-vocational – what if he also runs a business, or also teaches science and math? Is he a mathematician or a minister? Ironically, there was no disqualification against a corrupt individual running for office, or a known criminal, but there was a disqualification against a preacher? Having pointed out absurdities in their policy, Witherspoon sarcastically concluded:

I cannot help thinking that these difficulties are very considerable, and may occasion much litigation if the article of the constitution stands in the loose, ambiguous form in which it now appears; and therefore I would recommend the following alterations, which I think will make everything definite and unexceptionable:

“No clergyman of any denomination shall be capable of being elected a member of the Senate or House of Representatives because {here insert the grounds of offensive disqualification, which I have not been able to discover}. Provided always – and it is the true intent and meaning of this part of the constitution – that if at any time he shall be completely deprived of the clerical character by those by whom he was invested with it [that is, he is defrocked], as by deposition for cursing and swearing, drunkenness or uncleanness, he shall then be fully restored to all the privileges of a free citizen; his offence [of being a minister] shall no more be remembered against him; but he may be chosen either to the Senate or House of Representatives, and shall be treated with all the respect due to his brethren, the other members of Assembly.” 14

Witherspoon’s critique must have struck a chord. When Georgia re-wrote its constitution in 1798, the clause prohibiting ministers from state office was deleted and a strong declaration of the rights of religious persons was inserted 15 – a vast reversal from its first constitution.

It is not clear if Fea, in opposition to Jefferson, Witherspoon, and the United States Supreme Court, thinks it is appropriate to exclude clergy from holding public office. But he indisputably states that America’s Founders “thought it was a good idea for ministers to stay out of politics,” 16 a position he endorses. He couldn’t be more mistaken.

Throughout American history clergy have played a key role in American politics, some while holding office and others without doing so. Consider, for instance, those brave ministers who led the fight against slavery, opposed Indian removal, and advocated for civil rights. One strongly suspects that Fea would support the political activities of these ministers.

Fea, like many on the political left, is guilty of embracing a double standard. If a member of the clergy supports a policy he favors, that is a good thing. But if a minister takes a political stand of which he does not approve, that cannot be tolerated. In this case, it is noteworthy that he is opposing clergy listening to a speech by Donald Trump, a candidate whom Fea has publicly criticized. 17

This sort of hypocrisy is nothing new. John Adams observed this same behavior toward the patriotic preachers of his day, noting that:

It is curious to observe the conduct of the Tories [those who opposed the patriots] towards this sacred body. If a clergyman preaches against the principles of the Revolution and tells the people that upon pain of damnation they must submit to an established government of whatever character, the Tories cry him up as an excellent man and a wonderful preacher, invite him to their tables, procure him missions from the society and chaplainships to the navy, and flatter him with the hopes of lawn sleeves [i.e., a special church appointment]. But if a clergyman preaches Christianity, and tells the magistrates that they were not distinguished from their brethren for their private emolument [personal economic benefit] but for the good of the people – that the people are bound in conscience to obey a good government but are not bound to submit to one that aims at destroying all the ends of government – Oh, sedition! Treason! 18

Significantly, Adams goes on to specifically reject Fea’s position, declaring:

It is the duty of the clergy to accommodate their discourses to the times – to preach against such sins as are most prevalent and recommend such virtues as are most wanted [lacking]. For example, if exorbitant ambition and venality [public corruption and bribery] are predominant, ought they not to warn their hearers against these vices? If public spirit is much wanted [lacking], should they not inculcate this great virtue? If the rights and duties of Christian magistrates [public officials] and subjects are disputed, should they not explain them, show their nature, ends, limitations, and restrictions, how much soever it may move the gall [anger the critics] . . . 19

Adams rejoiced that concerning civil issues, “the pulpits have thundered”; 20 but today Fea would apparently have the pulpits (or at least those pulpits promoting views to which he is opposed) be silent.

As Fea must know, there are a host of books by historians that attest to the important role both office-holding and non-office holding clergy played in the War for Independence and the creation of the new national government. 21 Consider a few additional historical facts that Fea ignores:

  • Numerous individuals who served in formal ministry at some point in their lives also served in the Continental and Confederation Congresses, including John Witherspoon, Frederick Augustus Muhlenberg, Benjamin Contee, Abiel Foster, James Manning, Joseph Montgomery, Jesse Root, Hugh Williamson, Robert Treat Paine, Lyman Hall, Paine Wingate, and John Zubly. 22

  • The Rev. Jacob Green of New Jersey was chairman of the committee that drafted the state’s original constitution in 1776; 23 the Rev. Frederick Augustus Muhlenberg helped draft Pennsylvania’s 1776 constitution; 24 the Revs. Samuel Stillman, Robert Treat Paine, and Gad Hitchcock helped write Massachusetts’ 1780 constitution; 25 the Revs. John Bailey, David Rice, George Stovall Smith, Benedict Swope, Caleb Wallace, and James Crawford helped draft Kentucky’s original constitution of 1792; 26 the Rev. John Smith helped frame Ohio’s original constitution of 1802; 27 and the Rev. Amasa Learned helped write Connecticut’s first constitution following the Revolution. 28

  • Christian ministers were also at the forefront of the movement for a federal constitution. The Revs. Jeremy Belknap and Samuel Stanhope Smith became leaders in pointing out the defects of the Articles of Confederation, 29 joining their voices with those of the Rev. Dr. Witherspoon and the Rev. James Manning, both of whom had personally experienced its shortcomings while operating under it as members of Congress. 30

  • Several delegates at the Constitutional Convention were trained in ministry or theology, including Abraham Baldwin, James Wilson, Hugh Williamson, and Oliver Ellsworth. 31

  • When the federal Constitution was submitted to the states for ratification, nearly four dozen clergymen were elected as ratifying delegates, 32 and many of them played key roles in securing its adoption. For example, in Massachusetts, it appeared that the Constitution would be rejected until the efforts of the Rev. Samuel West 33 and the Rev. Samuel Stillman helped carry the day in support of the Constitution. 34 Benjamin Lincoln (one of George Washington’s most trusted generals during the final campaigns of the War for Independence) reported to his former Commander-in-Chief: “It is very fortunate for us that the clergy are pretty generally with us . . .” 35

  • In addition to ministers holding office, active Christian leaders and laymen also played a key role. According to the historian Stephen Marini, “Literally hundreds of [delegates to the U. S. Constitution ratification conventions] were Anglican vestrymen, Congregational deacons, and Presbyterian ruling elders. These were the highest offices available to laymen, empowering them to maintain the financial health of the parish, to enforce the moral norms of the church, and often to choose the minister of the congregation. Many hundreds more of the delegates were loyal parishioners who held lesser church offices: trustees, wardens, tithingmen, assessors, teachers, moderators, commissioners, and committeemen.” 36

So ministers were not only vital in helping secure America’s independence and its form of government but they were also at the forefront of celebrating the new federal Constitution. During the ratification parade in Philadelphia, signer of the Declaration Benjamin Rush happily reported:

The clergy formed a very agreeable part of the procession. They manifested by their attendance their sense of the connection between religion and good government. They amounted to seventeen in number. Four and five of them marched arm in arm with each other to exemplify the Union. Pains were taken to connect ministers of the most dissimilar religious principles together, thereby to show the influence of a free government in promoting Christian charity. The rabbi of the Jews locked in the arms of two ministers of the Gospel was a most delightful sight. There could not have been a more happy emblem. 37

When the first federal Congress convened, its members numbered several ministers, both active and inactive, including the Revs. Frederick Augustus Muhlenberg, John Peter Gabriel Muhlenberg, Abiel Foster, Benjamin Contee, Abraham Baldwin, Hugh Williamson, and Paine Wingate. In fact, the first Speaker of the U. S. House of Representatives was the Rev. Frederick Muhlenberg; and his is one of only two signatures appearing at the bottom of the Bill of Rights – which was intended to secure the right of every citizen – including ministers – to participate in the political process. This includes the First Amendment rights that protect the ability of ministers to publicly criticize the government, to speak freely about what is occurring in the civil arena, to join with other ministers and Christians to do the same, to express their personal religious convictions about any public policy issue, and to serve in public office!

And just as history does not demand the exclusion of ministers, neither does the Bible. Consider how often God sent His ministers to publicly confront civil leaders or expose their wicked policies:

    ➢ Elijah confronted civil leaders Ahab and Queen Jezebel over issues such as their unjust use of eminent domain, religious persecution, and subornation of perjury (1 Kings 21:1-24, 1 Kings 18:18).

    ➢ Isaiah confronted civil ruler Hezekiah over national security failures and issues related to the treasury (1 Chronicles 32:27-31, 2 Kings 20:12-19)

    ➢ Nathan confronted civil leader David over his wicked moral policies and practices (2 Samuel 12),

    ➢ Eliezer and Jehu confronted King Jehoshaphat over his blunders in foreign relations and ill-advised foreign alliances (2 Chronicles 19:1-2, 2 Chronicles 20:35-37)

    ➢ John the Baptist confronted civil leaders for their hypocrisy (Matthew 3:7)

    ➢ Jeremiah confronted King Zedekiah over numerous of his wicked public policies (Jeremiah 34)

    ➢ John the Baptist confronted King Herod over his divorce and marriage practices (Luke 13:32. Matthew 12:23, 23:33, 23:27)

    ➢ Samuel confronted King Saul over not fulfilling his assigned responsibilities (1 Samuel 13:1-14, I Samuel 15)

    ➢ Micaiah regularly confronted King Ahab over his wicked public policies (1 Kings 22:7-18)

    ➢ Gad confronted King David over wrong-headed public policies stemming from his own pride and arrogance (2 Samuel 24)

    ➢ Jesus refused to be intimidated by Herod (Luke 13:31-32) and confronted the teachers of the law (Matthew 23)

    ➢ Daniel confronted Nebuchadnezzar over his pride and arrogance (Daniel 4:1-27), and Belshazzar over his moral debauchery (Daniel 5:17-28)

    ➢ Azariah (along with eighty other priests) confronted King Uzziah for usurping religious practices through an improper expansion of government powers (2 Chronicles 26:16-21)

And God’s ministers not only called out bad civil leaders and pointed out unBiblical public policies, they also frequently partnered with civil leaders in constructing good public policies and offering sound guidance. For example:

    ➢ Elisha provided the King of Israel counsel and advice regarding military intelligence and policy (2 Kings 6)

    ➢ Nathan provided guidance to David on architectural issues (2 Samuel 7:1-13)

    ➢ Ezra gave strong counsel on marriage policy (Ezra 9-10), and Governor Nehemiah implemented that counsel into public policy (Nehemiah 8:1-6, 13:23-27)

    ➢ Paul provided civil leaders with guidance during times of impending disaster and natural calamity (Acts 27:9-12)

    ➢ Jeremiah provided military guidance to King Zedekiah (Jeremiah 21:1-10)

    ➢ King Joash pursued good policies as long as the priest Jehoiada provided him counsel, but when Joash lost that Godly input, his policies became wicked (2 Chronicles 24:1-2, 15-19)

    ➢ Isaiah provided guidance on national security issues and foreign policy to King Hezekiah (Isaiah 37)

The Bible is loaded – and almost overflowing – with such examples. But Dr. Fea holds an opposite view. In fact, in lamenting how unhistorical it was that 700 ministers should hear from a presidential candidate and consider becoming involved in politics in different ways, he condescendingly quipped:

There’s an old Baptist saying that goes something like this: “If you mix horse manure and ice cream it doesn’t do much to the manure, but it sure does ruin the ice cream. ” . . . For all those concerned about the witness of the Christian church in the world, let’s remember that the founders thought it was a bad idea to mix horse manure and ice cream. 38

The real horse manure is Dr. Fea’s claim that either the Founders or the Bible opposed the active participation of ministers in the civil arena.



Endnotes

1. See various of his articles criticizing those who hold such beliefs, including David Lane (“Why the Founding Fathers wanted to keep ministers from public office,” Religion News Service, August 15, 2016; David Barton; Mike Huckabee (“Why Huckabee May Have a Shot at the GOP Nomination,” philipvickersfithian.com, January 23, 2015; Focus on the Family (“Is America a Christian Nation? What Focus on the Family Gets Wrong,” philipvickersfithian.com, November 4, 2012; Eric Metaxas (“Burkholder on Metaxas,” philvickersfithian.com, September 26, 2012; and Peter Marshall (“Houston Chronicle Op-Ed,” philipvickersfithian.com, August 15, 2009. (Return)

2.Would you vote for this man?Patheos, February 15, 2012. (Return)

3.Why the Founding Fathers wanted to keep ministers from public office,” Religion News Service, August 15, 2016. (Return)

4. According to Francis Thorpe’s 1909 collection of state constitutions (Francis Newton Thorpe, The Federal and State Constitutions, Colonial Charters, and the Organic Laws of the State, Territories, and Colonies; Now or Heretofore Forming the United States of America. Washington, D.C. 1909), of the 46 states in the United States at that time, only 14 ever had a clergy-exclusion clause, and most of those were voluntarily repealed. Those 14 states: Delaware (1776, 1792, 1831), Florida (1838), Georgia (1777, 1789), Kentucky (1792, 1799, 1850), Louisiana (1812, 1845, 1864), Maryland (1776, 1851, 1867), Missouri (1820, 1865), Mississippi (1817), New York (1777, 1821), North Carolina (1776), South Carolina (1778,1790, 1865), Tennessee (1834, 1870), Texas (1836, 1845, 1866), and Virginia (1850, 1864). (Return)

5. McDaniel v. Paty, 435 U.S. 618 (1978). (Return)

6. The Constitution of the Sixteen States (Boston: Manning and Loring, 1797), p. 212, “The Constitution of Virginia” July 5, 1776, “...all ministers of the gospel, of every denomination, be incapable of being elected members…”(Return)

7. Thomas Jefferson, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Julian P. Boyd, editor (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1953), Vol. 8, p. 470, to Chelier de Chastellux on September 2, 1785. (Return)

8. This type of Virginia persecution occurred from Anglicans against non-Anglicans. For an example of what Baptists suffered in Virginia, see: William Cathcart, Baptist Patriots in the American Revolution (Philadelphia: S. A. George & Co., 1876), pp. 12-18; Isaac Backus, A History of New England, With Particular Reference to the Denomination of Christians Called Baptists (Newton, MA: Backus Historical Society, 1871), Vol. II, pp. 97-98; George Bancroft, A History of the United States of America (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1858), Vol. 1, pp. 449-450; Sanford Hoadley Cobb, The Rise of Religious Liberty in America Republicanism in Jefferson’s Virginia (New York: MacMillan, 1902), p. 112; Bruce Gourley, "An outline of Baptist Persecution in America," The Baptist Index (accessed August 17, 2016); Lewis Peyton Little, Imprisoned Preachers and Religious Liberty in Virginia (Lynchburg, VA: J. P. Bell Co., Inc., 1938), p. xiii; etc.(Return)

9. Thomas Jefferson, The Works of Thomas Jefferson, Paul Leicester Ford, editor (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1905), Vol. IX, p. 143, to Jeremiah Moore on August 14, 1800. (Return)

10. Thomas Jefferson, The Writings of Thomas Jefferson, Andrew A. Lipscomb, editor (Washington, D. C.: The Thomas Jefferson Memorial Association, 1903), Vol. VIII, pp. 3-4, to Rev. Charles Clay on January 27, 1790. (Return)

11. Rev. John B. Turpin, A Brief History of the Albemarle Baptist Association (Richmond, VA: The Virginia Baptist Historical Society, 1891), pp. 30-31. (Return)

12. The Federal and State Constitutions, Colonial Charter, and Other Organic Laws, Francis Newton Thorpe, editor (Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909), Vol. II, p. 785, “Constitution of Georgia – 1777,” Art. LXII. (Return)

13. John Witherspoon, The Works of John Witherspoon (Edinburgh: J. Ogle, Parliament-Square, 1815), Vol. IX, pp 220-223, “On the Georgia Constitution.” (Return)

14. John Witherspoon, The Works of John Witherspoon (Edinburgh: J. Ogle, Parliament-Square, 1815), Vol. IX, pp 220-223, “On the Georgia Constitution.” (Return)

15. The Federal and State Constitutions, Colonial Charter, and Other Organic Laws, Francis Newton Thorpe, editor (Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909), Vol. II, pp. 800-801, “Constitution of Georgia – 1798,” Art. IV, Sec. 10. (Return)

16.Why the Founding Fathers wanted to keep ministers from public office,” Religion News Service, August 15, 2016. (Return)

17.Historians Against Trump,” The Way of Improvements Leads Home, July 12, 2016. (Return)

18. John Adams, The Works of John Adams, Charles Francis Adams, editor (Boston: Charles C. Little and James Brown, 1851), Vol. IV, p. 55, “Novanglus: No. IV.” (Return)

19. John Adams, The Works of John Adams, Charles Francis Adams, editor (Boston: Charles C. Little and James Brown, 1851), Vol. IV, p. 56, “Novanglus: No. IV.” (Return)

20. John Adams, The Works of John Adams, Charles Francis Adams, editor (Boston: Charles C. Little and James Brown, 1851), Vol. 3, p. 476, “The Earl of Clarendon to William Pym,” January 20, 1766. (Return)

21. For example, Alice M. Baldwin, The New England Clergy and the American Revolution (1928; reprint, New York: Frederick Ungar, 1958) and Keith L. Griffin, Revolution and Religion: American Revolutionary War and the Reformed Clergy (New York: Paragon House, 1994). See also the excellent collection of political sermons from this era edited by Ellis Sandoz, Political Sermons of the American Founding Era 1730-1805 (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund Press, 1991). (Return)

22. See, John Sanderson, Biography of the Signers to the Declaration of Independence (Philadelphia: R. W. Pomeroy, 1823), Vol. V, pp. 102-104; Charles A. Goodrich, Lives of the Signers to the Declaration of Independence (New York: Thomas Mather, 1837), p. 113; Hubert Bruce Fuller, The Speakers of the House (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1909), pp. 22-23; William B. Sprague, Annals of the American Pulpit (New York: Robert Carter & Brothers, 1850), Vol. V, p. 488; The National Cyclopedia of American Biography (New York: James T. White & Company, 1897)), Vol. VII, p. 148; Memoir of the Rev. James Manning (Boston: Perkins & Marvin, 1839), pp. 4-5; James H. Marshall, The United States Manual of Biography and History (Philadelphia: Leary & Getz, 1857), p. 182; Biographical Directory of the United States Congress: 177-Present for Lyman Hall, Joseph Montgomery, Jesse Root, Paine Wingate, and John Zubly. See alsoHistory of Clergy in Congress,” Pew Research Center, January 5, 2015. (Return)

23. B.F. Morris, Christian Life and Character of the Civil Institutions of the United States, Developed in the Official and Historical Annals of the Republic (Philadelphia: George W. Childs, 1864), p. 366. (Return)

24. William Warren Sweet, The Story of Religion in America (New York: Harper & Brothers Publishers, 1950), p. 182. (Return)

25. Frank Moore, The Patriot Preachers of the American Revolution (New York: Charles T. Evans, 1862), p. 260; Appletons’ Cyclopedia of American Biography (New York: D. Appleton and Company, 1888), Vol. IV, s.v. “Robert Treat Paine”; William B. Sprague, Annals of the American Pulpit; or Commemorative Notices of Distinguished American Clergymen of the Various Denominations (New York: Robert Carter & Brothers, 1865), Unitarian Congregational: Vol. VIII, p. 29. (Return)

26. Mrs. William Preston Drake, Samuel M. Wilson, Mrs. William Breckenridge Ardery, Kentucky in Retrospect: Noteworthy Personages and Events in Kentucky History: 1792-1942 (Commonwealth of Kentucky: Sesquicentennial Commission, 1942), pp. 141-142, 151, 153, 179-180. (Return)

27.John Smith,” Ohio History Central (accessed on August 17, 2016). (Return)

28.Learned, Amasa (1750-1825),” Biographical Directory of the United States Congress (accessed on August 17, 2016). (Return)

29. James Hutchinson Smylie, American Clergymen and the Constitution of the United States of America (New Jersey: Princeton Theological Seminary, doctoral dissertation 1958), pp. 127-129. (Return)

30. James Hutchinson Smylie, American Clergymen and the Constitution of the United States of America (New Jersey: Princeton Theological Seminary, doctoral dissertation 1958), p. 139, 143. (Return)

31. Biographical Directory of the United States Congress: 177-Present for Abraham Baldwin and Hugh Williamson; “James Wilson,” University of St. Andrews (accessed on August 24, 2016); William Garrott Brown, The Life of Oliver Ellsworth (New York: The Macmillan Company, 1905), pp. 20-21. (Return)

32. John Eidsmoe, Christianity and the Constitution (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 1987), p. 352, n. 15. (Return)

33. James Hutchinson Smylie, American Clergymen and the Constitution of the United States of America (New Jersey: Princeton Theological Seminary Doctoral Dissertation, 1958), pp. 185-186; see also Alice M. Baldwin, The New England Clergy and the American Revolution (New York: Frederick Ungar, 1958), p. 145. (Return)

34. Frank Moore, The Patriot Preachers of the American Revolution (New York: Charles T. Evans, 1862), p. 260. (Return)

35. The Papers of George Washington, Dorothy Twohig, editor (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1997), Vol. 6, pp. 104-105, from Benjamin Lincoln on February 9, 1788. (Return)

36. Stephen A. Marini, “Religion, Politics, and Ratification,” in Religion in a Revolutionary Age, ed. Ronald Hoffman and Peter Albert (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1994), p. 189. (Return)

37. Benjamin Rush, Letters of Benjamin Rush, L. H. Butterfield, editor (Princeton: American Philosophical Society, 1951), Vol. I, p. 474, to Elias Boudinot on July 9, 1788. (Return)

38.Why the Founding Fathers wanted to keep ministers from public office,” Religion News Service, August 15, 2016. (Return)

This site belongs to WallBuilders, LLC, a Texas Limited Liability Corporation | PO Box 397 | Aledo, Texas | 76008 | (817) 441-6044 | Contact Us
powered by ChaseComputerServices.com   |   design by Blepo.   Terms and Conditions  Privacy Policy